r/SneerClub archives
newest
bestest
longest
62

“Therapy is for gullible people, women,”

Lmao I thought you were joking, he actually said this.

“When I say that 80% of all therapists are incompetent, it’s because I have a fundamental belief that all proportions are basically either 80% or zero.”

[deleted]

When I say that 80% of therapists are incompetent, it is more of a general observation of the nature of the world rooted in the Pareto Principle, Price’s Law, and the Peter Principle.

I love reifying presently existing social forms, in fact that’s all I do all day, is reify presently existing social forms.

That's too charitable -- the number is definitely an ass-pull.
Oh yeah, that's how most applications of the Pareto principle go
"Hey, it's really counter-intuitive how you can so frequently find this ratio turning up in social science, must mean that whenever I think about society I should cast it in terms of this ratio"
it's awesome how many of these "principles" have been made up and promulgated to justify this misanthropic, almost Randian belief system. Thinking about getting a career as a professional social form-reifier oh yeah and also Pareto was a fascist
lol you don't need to go that far into the critique of political economy stuff to rinse this, it's far stupider than that
i'm just toiling away all day in the social form factory, reifying social forms , and you want to outsource my job to some 16-year old overseas who can do it for pennies on the dollar. you god damn neo liberal.
lol
but actually the concept is useful to explain the appeal of Pareto, who by the way was a big fan of ~~Herbert Spencer~~ Mussolini
I’d say 80% of claimed applications of the Pareto principle are ass-pulls.
Starting with Pareto himself, most likely.
If you keep reifying stuff you’ll go blind.

You have absolutely nothing to defend your argument with, whereas I have the full force of the Pareto Principle, Megan’s Law, the Peter Principle, Murphy’s Law, Boyle’s Law, Bloch’s Principle of Hope, Stigler’s Law, Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, Greenspun’s tenth rule, Godwin’s Law, Say’s Law, Newton’s third law, L’Hôpital’s Rule, Coleslaw, and the Miranda Rule on my side

Utter quality. I love the inclusion of the all-important Coleslaw.

I think this is satire? It reads like a copypasta
That is 100% a joke, an utter quality joke (you also might notice that its author is posting in this thread too 👀).
brigading, folks, more and more people are doing it
It's like [Fallacy Man](https://existentialcomics.com/comic/9) meets Yugioh.
you really shouldn't underestimate its value

Most therapists […] offer no significant measurable improvements

> mfw i see this

> googles “how effective is therapy”

> finds this

The strongest support exists for CBT of anxiety disorders, somatoform disorders, bulimia, anger control problems, and general stress. Eleven studies compared response rates between CBT and other treatments or control conditions. CBT showed higher response rates than the comparison conditions in 7 of these reviews and only one review reported that CBT had lower response rates than comparison treatments. In general, the evidence-base of CBT is very strong.

i dont get it

The study he cited was a meta-analysis of the effectiveness of CBT in treating _depression._ Specifically depression, nothing else. So yea, this guy owns.

Gilded

-70 points

The marketplace of ideas at work….

bla bla bla capitalism.

…pretty sure Scott approves of therapy in general, wonder what OP thinks of that

I recall long ago Scott mentioned a good portion of his time being a gatekeeper from stimulant abuse or something. I can imagine like other psychiatrists, he may require therapy as a prerequisite to being prescribe psychiatric drugs, if at least not to turn into a legal pusher / solve the real problem.