r/SneerClub archives
newest
bestest
longest
"The Metasophist" wants to replace existing educational and political hierarchies with...a system of tiered science fair projects (https://www.themetasophist.com/chapter/ch-6-how-to-select-an-elite)
13

According to measures such as score effectiveness, the German Army also outperformed other armies during WW2.

According to measures such as “who actually won WWII,” I would argue there’s actually a compelling case that the German army did not outperform other armies during WWII. But maybe I’m just not meta enough to understand.

It's a little known fact, so I'll forgive you, but Hitler's dog [Blondi](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/ac/Bundesarchiv_B_145_Bild-F051673-0059%2C_Adolf_Hitler_und_Blondi_auf_dem_Berghof_%28cropped%29.jpg/220px-Bundesarchiv_B_145_Bild-F051673-0059%2C_Adolf_Hitler_und_Blondi_auf_dem_Berghof_%28cropped%29.jpg) gave a triple xp buff to the German army while it was alive. Since the buff from a familiar is relative to its size, FDR's dog [Fala](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/45/FDR-Fala-1940-crop.jpg/220px-FDR-Fala-1940-crop.jpg) was no match. This is why the Nazis finished ahead on points.

I don’t propose that as a replacement, but actually as a separate programme so that people learn to self-organise and self-direct at an early age (and don’t need to toady to higher-ups in whatever hierarchy they find themselves in). Top-down hierarchies are good in some areas and in some things, but probably not in areas meant to foster creativity.

Plus, I also state that projects could be in areas other than science, such as art or business.

I'm taking you at your word when you say you want to replace the elite
I propose a way to select "an" elite not "the" elite. There are many different types of elites (left-wing, right-wing, business, cultural, academic) so this elite would just be a subset of a society's broader elite. I don't propose abolishing any organisation or institution in the entire online book (aside from shadow banks), so universities, political parties, and international institutions would continue to generate their own elites. Finally, it would just take such a long time for my system to generate any complement elite that current elites will have long left the scene, so it's not possible to even envision replacing them. For example, the stages take place over the ages of 15 to 30. Given that my influence is currently zero (e.g. 130 Twitter followers, unknown in any community, absent on most social media) let's say it takes 20 years for me to have enough influence to actually start this system at whatever scale. That means those trained through my system would just be entering the workforce in about 50 years, when those currently in university would probably be at the point of retiring.
You know what, I still think you're crazy but I apologize for sneering at you, do your thing.
Fair enough!
hey dude, [reading suggestion](https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-1/mswv1_17.htm)
>We Chinese often say, "Things that oppose each other also complement each other." This is actually a useful text explaining among many other things the relationship between SneerClub and its targets. The Hegelian synthesis that will emerge from this contradiction will be very interesting.
well, strictly speaking it wouldn't be a Hegelian synthesis since Marx and his followers reject Hegel's idealism. instead we'd use scientific analysis to understand the material nature of the contradiction. for instance, we can examine the class structure rationalists are embedded in. Once we see that they're mostly highly-paid members of the programming petit bourgeoise, many elements of their behavior becomes easier to predict. this allows us to post better sneers, heightening the contradictions