• David GerardOPMA
    link
    English
    17
    edit-2
    4 months ago

    lol i basically wrote that article

    i’m sorry, i was describing something that is garbage

    the short description is “lisp machines but networked, for nazis, and they don’t fucking work”

    i’ve always pronounced it ER-bit

    • @selfMA
      link
      English
      104 months ago

      lisp machines but networked

      urbit’s even stupider than this, cause lisp machines were infamously network-reliant (MIT, symbolics, and LMI machines wouldn’t even boot properly without a particular set of delicately-configured early network services, though they had the core of their OS on local storage), so yarvin’s brain took that and went “what if all I/O was treated like a network connection”, a decision that causes endless problems of its own

      speaking of, one day soon I should release my code that sets up a proper network environment for an MIT cadr machine (which mostly relies on a PDP-10 emulator running one of the AI lab archive images) and a complete Symbolics Virtual Lisp Machine environment (which needs a fuckton of brittle old Unix services, including a particular version of an old pre-ntp time daemon (this is so important for booting the lisp machine for some reason) and NFSv1 (with its included port mapper dependency and required utterly insecure permissions)) so there’s at least a nice way to experience some of this history that people keep stealing from firsthand

    • @V0ldek
      link
      English
      8
      edit-2
      4 months ago

      lol i basically wrote that article

      Oops

      To me it looked like someone wrote some babble about the architecture and then a Responsible Adult came in and added the thinly veiled sneers of “all they built is a text board, Yarvin is a certified idiot, none of this works”

      I might read the primary source on this tomorrow if I hate myself hard enough, I am fascinated by why you need two languages and two OS things to run a nazi chatroom, sounds like some absolute pinnacle of human lack of thought

      EDIT: I guess the actual concept might be so insane that there’s no way to write an article about it that makes sense and doesn’t use expletives

      • Clifton Royston
        link
        fedilink
        12
        edit-2
        4 months ago

        @V0ldek @dgerard

        Yeah, there’s a number of people here who actually met Yarvin before he

        1. became a complete asshole, you can not even imagine,
        2. became a proud fascist and *monarchist*, and
        3. lost his mind.

        Many of us also have SW experience and have tried to look into Urbit and all came to the same conclusion - it all seems to be based on both giving stupid names to existing concepts, and blindly doing the opposite of whatever anybody has done before without regard to reason.

        • Clifton Royston
          link
          fedilink
          94 months ago

          @V0ldek @dgerard

          IIRC, a trivial but telling example of the latter is that for whatever reason, Yarvin decided that in all languages and code for all things Urbit, the boolean value true should be represented in binary form as 0, and false should be represented as non-zero.

          Now it’s fundamentally *arbitrary* whether 0 represents false or true, but deliberately making it the opposite of virtually every modern language implementation seems a perfect recipe for introducing unnecessary bugs.

          • @bitofhope
            link
            English
            64 months ago

            Bourne shell inspiring yet another language!

            • Clifton Royston
              link
              fedilink
              74 months ago

              @bitofhope

              Yeah, that was the only motivation I could think of. And even there it doesn’t mean true/false, it means “no errors” and that only sometimes.

      • David GerardOPMA
        link
        English
        94 months ago

        I guess the actual concept might be so insane that there’s no way to write an article about it that makes sense and doesn’t use expletives

        this is basically the problem. there was an article there already but it was based entirely on urbit’s descriptions of itself, which were all cultist gibberish. I went searching and found literally every Wikipedia-quality source I could. Most of these were about the people, not the tech.