@asklemmy@lemmy.world @asklemmy@lemmy.ml @ask @casualconversation @casualuk to what extent is AI useful to young learners for learning a language ??
None at all, I believe it will actively harm learning in general.
@slazer2au you’ve put in your view in one single sentence. But I know that you have a very good understanding of the entire system.
Can you please make your reason more and more elaborate, in your free time ???
Each time a technology has come around to assist in learning, skills have been lost.
Examples are calculators have killed off mental arithmetic.
Smart phones have lowered students scores in general to the point that schools that have no phone policies show improvement back to pre smartphone levels.
Not to mention the whole remote learning during covid and how bad those students are performing.What makes you think the next technology is going to magically fix things when its trained on stolen and bad information.
I’ll eat the downvotes: AI is most useful early on when your speaking skills would burden a native speaker. Having conversations, even with AI, where you are on-the-spot generating language and figuring out how to say novel things is really valuable.
And I don’t really see what the problem is, exactly, within the bounds of learning a language (and not making it your companion). AI hallucinates facts, but I don’t think it hallucinates grammar or vocabulary.
Open question of whether it is good at corrections or not. After conversations, I would ask it review what I’ve written and give me corrections. I would try to understand what my error was and evaluate the correction. There’s lots of “how would a native speaker say this” type questions that grammar guides aren’t great with. But that’s really where I think you might get into trouble: relying on completely on AI to tell you how to speak the language, but I understand the temptation!
But as far as absorbing content, you’re better off with the amazing variety of human-made fare that’s available on the interwebsand actually finding some real people to talk to.
Language is a thing that large language models are pretty good at in the scheme of things. My only concern is that the tone of an LLM might be bad to adopt. But if you’re watching and absorbing enough human made content, it should be okay.
I agree with this.
You don’t ask Lemmy about AI and expect an unbiased response.





