Selection. The majority of masculine European men perished in WW1 and WW2. What was left results in what you see today.
Genuine answer: I think it’s the colonialism. If you’re going to Genocide an entire continent and take people’s land, it helps to have a culture that values a masculine capacity for violence.
So it’s not so much that American men “value being masculine” more than Europeans do, but that American masculinity is decidedly more shitty. It values aggression more than its European cultural counterpart.
And even then, it’s really just hegemonic white masculinity that I’m talking about here. White conceptions of masculinity, though normative, aren’t the same as black or indigenous masculinities
Marketing
People covet what they don’t have or can’t have.
Oh yes, the Rebublic of Europe. The only reason i can come up with is that bad tendencies reach us with a delay, and because US is a shithole with much more established right-wing brainrot conservative narrative in politics.
Probably (as a vast vast generalisation), because European men are secure in their masculinity, while US men aren’t.
Nah, they obviously hate masculinity.
Tell that to hot, oiled, italian men in italy. Or spain or france or whatever. Like 70% of men there would probably say they feel totally masculine, and they’re unlikely to be toxicly masculine like in US.
Holy shit OP, you need to legit seek out some therapy and not rely on Lemmy for something so important. These opinions are kinda next level.
Maybe you need to go to the gym?
Maybe you need to treat yourself kinder and stop comparing everything as if it’s a competition where it’s over for you forever if you see someone taller/stronger/prettier/richer or whatever trait du jour is in vogue right now.
(And no, one of your eyes isn’t smaller than the other, you don’t need to go under the knife, you’ll just end up looking like a republican woman/someone wearing a skinsuit.)
Age with grace and without care. Get scars to prove you exist, tattoo yourself and paint the canvas you have to luve with. Spend time in the sun, wear sunscreen, swim in the sea, go fucking live your life instead of looking for who has it better and complaining that they have it but you don’t; You’re just making yourself miserable.
Is this a joke or did OP edit their original post? :/
Look at OP’s other posts
Jesus Christ.
OP, go see a therapist
I think they’re American so probably can’t? :/
‘Cause we’re the land of rebellion against the crown and rootin’ tootin’ cowboys!!!
The image sold to America is that of rugged independence. Boldly surviving via your own grit on the frontier after having thrown off the yoke of “the man”.
This is absolute horse shit, but that’s what they grow up with.
I can only speak for Germany here but German ooga-booga masculinity destroyed the continent twice over and killed almost 100 million people in 25 years. Those wars killed most of those men and convincing new men that such masculinity is the way is a hard sell. It’s making a comeback these days though now that the old generation isn’t there to remind them of where it leads.
I also suspect that the US deliberately promotes this masculinity because of its Militarism. The ultimate expression of the masculine ideal is some form of soldier. Duty to, honor by, and violence for, the state. My grandfather would have had a thing or two to say about it.
Militarism builds on the rugged individualism that is associated with settling a new content and expansion to the west and beyond.
Have you looked at your Police recently? Absolute remorseless thugs
🌎🧑🚀🔫👨🚀
Idk, it seems to me they just enjoyed getting fucked in the ass, first by their Führer, and then by the Allies. that’s not exactly what I’d call masculinity, but everyone has their own opinion.
Your American is showing.
and homophobia.
Looking at the account history, I’m thinking more their troll is showing.
? 🤡 It just annoys me when people talk nonsense.
So why do you share your thoughts then?
🤨
Settler colonialism.
You forgot the other half: why do women care about men being masculine?
It was and is a cultural imperative. If you are not masculine, you are feminine, thusly weak.
Women are allowed to cry, boys and men are not. Crying shows weakness and is a liability.
Boys are conditioned to not cry, but to replace it with anger. Anger is power, sadness is weakness.
Women are taught the same thing. You don’t want a weak, sensitive man, you want a powerful man who can protect you and fuck you hard.
So women are taught this, and any guy who would like to have a woman in his life has to measure up. Be big, be strong, be rugged or you will never have a woman. Women are taught to reject anyan that does not measure up. If she chooses a man that doesn’t meet the expectation, she will face judgement And ridicule of her family, friends and society at large.
You can be dumb as a rock, mean, even ugly, but whatever you do, don’t be weak.
Please seek therapy
Lol, why do Americans think therapy is the solution to every problem
because there are things that most people find hot, and you can’t change that simply by appealing to their conscience.
What is “hot” has been well analyzed. Read The Erotic Mind by Jack Morin.
Thinking about what is erotic does not ruin it as many seem to think. In fact, you can cultivate your erotic desires and make conscious choices about them, rather than just accepting what you have been taught by society at large.
I think the better question is, why do men think that women care about men being masculine?
I know a lot of other women and they don’t think the way you think we do. You’re just saying a bunch of stereotypes and acting like they’re true, for both men and women.
Perhaps you should test your theories. Cry in public. See what happens. Most people will either give you space, or respond with genuine concern. Most people aren’t assholes.
I wish you were right and that I was wrong. The world would be a lot better place if this were true.
However, look around and tell me what you see.
I did. Everything I said is from personal experience.
Actually, I’m a sociologist from London UK, and have spent years analyzing this phenomenon. The USA is generally obsessed with bigger, larger, more; e.g. children in school are already trained that the USA is the best country in the entire world, and they are also as individuals stimulated to put themselves in the best light. Seen from the outside, US Americans love the Hollywood sparkle, they love hype, they love bravura, the excitement. In contrast, Europeans love a plate with spaghetti and a nice espresso.
Actually, I’m a sociologist from London UK
Are you sure you’re not from Zurich?
https://sh.itjust.works/comment/28697622
Or are you from the big apple?
https://sh.itjust.works/comment/28704252
Or what about Bulgaria?
https://sh.itjust.works/comment/28749060
Or Texas?
https://sh.itjust.works/comment/27585079
Or are you from Madrid?
https://sh.itjust.works/comment/28114450
Or are you Polish?
https://sh.itjust.works/comment/27566788
Maybe you’re German?
https://sh.itjust.works/comment/28073677
Or maybe you just talk bollocks?..
Perhaps they’re bad at geography?
Thanks for pointing these out! I can’t figure out whether they’re just a compulsive liar, or just an occasional troll. Likely using genAI in some of their comments, and one of their comments indicate they use genAI generally. Account is 2 month old, and the things they post, and where they post to seem akin to karma-farming, but maybe with some experimentation. Not enough evidence to conclude but I wonder if this is a bot account or maybe just an occasional troller.
Edit: found a comment that they admit to some trolling, https://sh.itjust.works/post/69781838/28516004
Aw it went from legendary to boring. That’s a block I guess.
What in the world.
This comment is just hogwash observation.
Post your research.
Not sure why you get downvoted for asking for evidence, as one should. But anw, this is likely a troll comment. See the comment by Zombie@feddit in this thread pointing out other identities they have allegedly taken.
obsessed with bigger, larger

incredible
I would love it if you’d be willing to post some of the research you’d encountered in one of the social science-y communities, like !sociology@a.gup.pe or !psychology@lemmy.world
European here - holy shit have you been reading my mail?
I blame cowboys. Or at least their portrayal in media.
The Boomers and Xers in the US were raised on action heroes. Big strong men that weren’t afraid o’ nothing. They had big egos, big guns, and big balls. They solved every problem by either killing or fucking.
So that’s what they thought a man should be. As we’ve become a little more conscious about what we should be teaching our kids, each generation has been gradually less focused on those ideals.
Yeah! and being naked cowboys in the showers together waiting to be sucked and wanting to suck cowboy cock. Uh wait.
Really most kids are very isolated. Educators burn out and can’t raise your kids for you. Parents are burned out as well. So media is the parent.
They’re insecure with unhealthy ideas about what a man is and does.
European men behave like touchy bitches, I really don’t understand how you can think that you are better than American men in any way. I’m European btw.
Congrats, you sound like the average Yankee!
Idk man, I just a woman that has dated American and European men. American men are fragile weirdos, the ones on steroids or the hunter redneck types are basically uneducated cave men that think they’re smart because their mommies love them and kiss their asses. Its really pathetic when they try and manipulate too, because it’s obvious they think everyone is as dumb as they are.
At least European men talk to me like I’m just another person and not a sex doll retard.














