I’ll be updating this every week now to keep it going. I got 2 new voters from last week bringing it up to 33 overall… I’ve added a Wiki Page with the top 40 now but only Piefed based users will be able to see it.

  1. Breaking Bad: 86
  2. The Good Place: 68 (-1)
  3. Futurama: 50
  4. Better Call Saul: 46 (+2)
  5. Stranger Things: 40 (-1)
  6. The Expanse: 36 (-1)
  7. Band of Brothers: 35 (+5)
  8. The Wire: 34 (+7)
  9. Chernobyl: 32 (+7)
  10. The Simpsons: 31 (-3)
  11. Game of Thrones: 29 (-3)
  12. Community: 28 (-3)
  13. Cowboy Bebop: 27 (-3)
  14. Star Trek: TNG: 27 (-3)
  15. Andor: 27 (-2)
  16. Mr. Robot: 26 (-2)
  17. Severance: 26
  18. Star Trek: DS9: 26 (+2)
  19. The Office (USA): 22 (-1)
  20. Black Mirror: 22 (-1)

So anyone who hasn’t, list your top 10 favourite shows. Your 10th choice will give the show 1 point, your 9th will give it to 2 points etc with the 1st choice getting 10 points. Eurovision style.

    • golli@sopuli.xyz
      2·
      1 month ago

      For me the question is whether or not one should include unfinished series at all. With my list I made the decision to include some like e.g. Futurama, which technically isn’t finished as it was recently rebooted, however is a bit more open-ended (similar to simpsons), but exclude others like Severance.

      The likes of game of thrones and Westworld have taught me to not rank shows until they have concluded. Westworld season 1 is goated and would probably make my top 10, but it just fell off after. Right now Severance is amazing, but if they don’t manage to tie up the mystery nicely the whole show might not hold up after all, just as rewatching got just feels wrong knowing where it eventually leads to.

      • TheUnicornOfPerfidy@feddit.ukEnglish
        2·
        1 month ago

        I hear you. I feel like the signs were there with all of them though. WW could have just been one season. It had such a strong conclusion to s1 that anything after was going to be incredibly hard to get right. (I did realy enjoy season 2 as well though)
        GoT was inconsistent from the beginning. Some great episodes and some less great. I think it was the hazard of doing fantasy TV at that level. No one had done it before and they didn’t know what they were getting themselves into.
        HoTD feels very consistent and thought out. It starts with the confidence that GoT doesn’t have until s3. Still, considering the lack of love for s2 I’m worried about the next one. I’ll change my votes if and when I need to. Maybe Silo will make it on to my list

        And don’t talk to me about Severance. I don’t need another Lost. 😆