Our path to better working conditions lies through organizing and striking, not through helping our bosses sue other giant mulitnational corporations for the right to bleed us out.

  • deborah
    link
    English
    195 months ago

    Doctorow’s had some pretty bad takes, honestly, for all I agree with him on some things. His review of Naomi Klein’s Doppleganger – a book which explores conspiracy theories and how they capture people – reduces the entire book, incorrectly, to his own political soapbox:

    Fundamentally: Klein is a leftist, Wolf was a liberal.

    This is, frankly, juvenile. Not every bad thing in the world can be mapped on to one’s particular soapboxes. Treating GenAI as Good because Copyright is Bad is exactly in character for him.

    (Also Cory gets smug about releasing his novels CC, as if all working writers can do that, but I’m sure it helps the family finances that his wife is an executive at Disney. It’s great to use money from one of copyright’s biggest monsters to act self-righteous about other people trying to make a living.)

    • @wizardbeard@lemmy.dbzer0.com
      link
      fedilink
      English
      10
      edit-2
      5 months ago

      his wife is an executive at Disney

      Wait. What? Holy shit, every good goddamn thing he’s ever released regarding copyright and intellectual property needs a big bold disclaimer about that in front then.

      Fucker’s talking out both sides of his mouth.

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_Taylor_(businesswoman)

      In 2017, Disney acquired Makie Labs technology and personnel for an undisclosed figure.

      In keeping with the strategic acquisition, Ms Taylor is now the Director, StudioLab at The Walt Disney Studios. In that role she is responsible for ensuring that Disney continues to invest in the intersection between online tech and content distribution.

      I’m sorry, in non-executive speak, doesn’t that heavily imply that she at least oversees some work on DRM? Any content distribution method Disney touches with a 40-foot pole is going to have DRM methodology.

      Motherfucker.

      • flere-imsaho
        link
        English
        75 months ago

        so should he have divorced her in 2017 to prove his ideological purity?

        (waves to the local chapter of the leftist circular firing squad)

        • deborah
          link
          English
          95 months ago

          To be clear, I was critiquing his smug intolerance to be people who don’t meet his standards of so-called leftist perfection, when he, himself, is as complex as anyone else. I was not critiquing his being married or his living under capitalism.

          • flere-imsaho
            link
            English
            55 months ago

            fwiw i was mostly annoyed by the “his wife is doing what” in the comment i was answering directly – going after him just because of his wife would be like going after varoufakis just because his wife is supposedly the heroine of blur’s “common people”.

            and i happily agree that doctorow could dispense with his privilege, tone down the smugness and try for less shallow takes once in a while.

        • flere-imsaho
          link
          English
          65 months ago

          (if we were to question bonafides of leftist intellectuals[1] just because they are supported by someone belonging to the moneyed class, or come from the moneyed class themselves, we’d need to start with certain mr. marx, comrades. and numerous others.)


          1. however you value doctorow’s qualities as an intellectual. ↩︎

          • @gerikson
            link
            English
            75 months ago

            One of my fav Marx anecdotes is no matter how tough economically the family had it, they never dispensed with the maid. Tbf maid wages were prolly really low, and the maid probably made Mrs Marx’ life easier, but I also don’t think Marx ever thought of the maid’s work as Labor.

            • deborah
              link
              English
              95 months ago

              Marx (who to be fair was operating in a very different global economy) explicitly excluded servants and other service labor from the proletariat, because he had an extremely industrial (cough gendered) definition of “productive labour.” That being said, he was friends, intellectual collaborators, and possibly lovers with the housekeeper.

              Disclaimer: I am no marx historian; my knowledge of marxist theory tends toward literary analysis. I may be simplifying to the point of wrong.